Comments: SF book meme

You made it all the way through the Silmarillion?

I'm impressed.

I fell asleep about 10 pages in and never picked it up again.

Posted by Harvey at November 17, 2006 03:01 PM

That's the reaction that I've heard from lots of people. You have to wade through about 40-50 pages of the creation of the world stuff before you get into the mythos of the Tolkienverse. Without that background, the whole Silmarillion doesn't make sense.

Actually, the Silmarillion makes sense out of a lot of the "historical" references through the LOTR, which was kind of cool. The next time I reread the trilogy, I had a better understanding of what was happening.

Posted by physics geek at November 17, 2006 03:21 PM

And why is the first Harry Potter listed? HP didn't become a juggernaut from which all flee until the fourth book in the series. The Book of the New Sun is listed as one work.

On the other hand, Cordwainer Smith gets a short story anthology counted as a novel. As does Harlan Ellison, plus a collection of stories by other people that he edited. Why not "Astounding/Analog, 1953-2002"?

It's not a bad list for "most influential." Just needs to be better defined. And, since it's "most influential," not "best" or "favorite," there needs to be more unreadable stuff. "Influential" lists always have more unreadable stuff.

Of the few books you haven't read, I'd recommend starting with New Sun, followed by Rogue Moon and Cities in Flight. If you haven't read any Cordwainer Smith, throw him in there.

Posted by Bob Hawkins at November 17, 2006 04:51 PM

I've read several Cordwainer Smith short stories and thought that they were great. I'l take a gander as soon as I can grab a copy.

Posted by physics geek at November 17, 2006 10:01 PM

Ellison's "I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream", seemed to me to be much more important.

I kept looking for Orwell's "1984", especially with the parallels in current events.

Nope, sorry, can't buy this list, and the only one I HAVEN'T read is, "The Book of the New Sun" by Wolfe (which I plan to rectify ASAP).

But then the SF Book Club has never been known for it's literary (as opposed to commercial) acumen. Some of the crap they've put out makes Herbert's, "Battlefield Earth", look like Shakespeare.


Posted by nofile404 at November 19, 2006 02:28 PM

They left out

The Retief stories

Commander Grimes and the Rim stories

Startide rising by Brin

Various Pournell/Niven works

David Drake's stuff

Barry B Longyear, (The circus world series)

The Marching Morons by Kornbluth

All of the Xanth books


Finally, how bout the ones you hate? My personally worst author is Philip K Dick. His books are ones you can't put down, you have to fling them in the trash with great force.

Posted by Frank Borger at November 22, 2006 08:25 AM

Hello! Nice design on this site, great info.

Posted by Alisaeum at March 19, 2007 12:11 PM

Hello Sirs, I'm very sorry for my post
avs anti virus antivirus aol download norton anti virus protection mcafre anti virus antivirus for technician 90 free antivirus free mcaffee antivirus downloads anti virus protection programs free download anti virus run norton antivirus aol safety and security center and antivirus problem uninstall etrust ez antivirus antivirus ceenter microsoft and antivirus antivirus status window avg free antivirus free mcafee anti virus download instll aol antivirus avg antivirus free update aol antivirus games anti virus protection download norton antivirus protction norton antivirus systems antivirus detection rates online tech remote removal virus and spyware and award winning antivirus and removal freedownloads anti virus panda antivirus download antivirus protection mcafree anti virus antivirus support

Posted by http://vkouevrh.notlong.com at May 8, 2007 08:28 PM

Hello Sirs, I'm very sorry for my post
norton antivirus software uninstall anti virus sorftware axim x5 antivirus software antivirus auto update stopsign antivirus mcafee antivirus software antivirus and lowest memory usage identifying multiple antivirus running programs what antivirus software does computerhelpsos use free antivirus download free antivirus removal aol antivirus and repeated messages nortonanti virus anti virus software reviews aol downloads anti virus free mcfee securtiy antivirus software free mcafee anti virus download free antivirus aol software avg antivirus free update antivirus auto update mcaffe antivirus updating norton antivirus norton antivirus systems download anti virus protection antivirus 20error 20killers freedownloads anti virus avg antivirus protection noon anti virus nortan anti virus mcafee antivirus protection

Posted by http://tfqmj.notlong.com at May 8, 2007 09:02 PM

book buy discount guest site tramadol [url=http://buy-tramadol.fawfy.com]book buy discount guest site tramadol[/url]

Posted by sxtem at October 17, 2007 01:56 PM

buy tramadol [url=http://utexyun.fawfy.com]buy tramadol[/url]

Posted by krmik at October 24, 2007 04:08 AM


Posted by wbvrg at October 24, 2007 07:54 AM

echinococcus granulosum
honda trx350te
steyr daimler puch

Posted by wvrtr at October 24, 2007 09:34 AM

1999 subaru impreza wrx sti
alfa romeo gtv twin spark
citroen h vans

Posted by gwhzg at October 24, 2007 10:38 AM

land rover discovery manual transmission
jaguar merritt island
mazda millenia radio

Posted by ujtwj at October 24, 2007 11:20 AM

agcode buy online tramadol [url=http://iylaga.vtook.com]agcode buy online tramadol[/url]

Posted by zamfc at November 14, 2007 01:50 PM

filing income tax buy tramadol [url=http://ainqi.vtook.com]filing income tax buy tramadol[/url]

Posted by uxeun at November 14, 2007 02:19 PM