Comments: Waxing Symbolic, Again


The man you remember from that book renounced his citizenship. It was not taken from him. He disliked America so much, he went to the trouble of informing the US State Department that he no longer wished to be a US citizen. The problem was, like all lefty ass-hats (a little Rachel nostalgia for me), he didn't think the problem through. He could not become a citizen of another country, because he was not a citizen of ANY country, so he had to live out the rest of his life (40+ years?) on a ship. When he was transferred to other ships, they had to do it by launch, as he was not allowed to leave any ship while in port, as he had no passport, or equivalent.

As a child, (I'm early 30's), we also learned about this man. He was used by the teacher as a shining example of someone who stuck by their convictions, even when it was inconvenient. I never bothered to learn more about him, as the teacher probably hoped we wouldn't. His "sacrifice" was a reason that I hated America for so long, even while in the Marine Corps. It was only after I opened my eyes and looked around that I realize that I had been lied to. Thank you for reminding me about this man. I will now use him again as motivation, but this time, as a shining example of what NOT to do.

Posted by LC The Humble Devildog at May 6, 2004 03:33 AM

I know that sort of feeling too - of not knowing where 'home' is when people ask - because I've moved around so much. I was even born on the move - in Erie - but never lived there.

I find home to be (tritely) wherever the heart is.

Great post, and sounds like a great read. I'm going to buy it.

Posted by maura at May 6, 2004 06:02 PM

Wow, Devildog, I honestly never looked at it from that angle. I can see, too, how easily it could be misrepresented like that.

Makes me wonder what my 16 year old knows about the story all of a sudden. Hell, for that matter, my 9 year old is reading on a high school level and I'm homeschooling her. I might give it to her too. (I just sometimes worry that while she can read the words and comprehend them, there's still more there she can't quite "get" yet, the nuances that she's just not got the life experience to fully grasp.)

Like Mama (I'm 44, maybe the way it was presented to us is the difference between a generation?) I was always struck by how sad it was that he couldn't go home and that they wouldn't let him "take it back." (As an anecdotal aside, I'm also a former military brat and was definitely raised similarly!)

Anyhow, while inspiring a patriotism and feeling of pride in me, it also always made me feel sad. It seemed like the worst sort of cruelty to me and yet he brought it on himself.

I know for a certainty it was instrumental in my lifelong determination to never say something I wouldn't want to be called on.

Posted by Kate at May 6, 2004 11:10 PM

In the book, he was pointedly named, "Richard Nolan."

It was based on a true story, the facts of which I also forget.

Posted by The Commissar at May 13, 2004 10:26 AM

poker me up

Posted by poker me up at December 30, 2004 02:22 PM

Interesting article and comments. Going to link to your site on buy womens leather wallet not too relevant to leather wallets but your thread is cool.

Posted by shop womens leather wallets at March 28, 2005 06:45 PM

Interesting article and comments. I am going to put your site on buy mans leather wallet here.

Posted by mens shop leather wallets at March 28, 2005 06:59 PM
Post a comment

Remember personal info?